Editorial
A themed investment fund ranked first and up sharply; why the reader could not explain its contents and costs and passed
The situation
On a brokerage ranking, a themed investment fund was in first place. It showed a large gain over the past year, and the words “everyone is buying it” caught my eye.
What stands out
- The gain shown is past performance. It does not promise future results. If a fund rose 40% in one year, it can fall in the next.
- An investment fund charges a yearly cost called the trust fee while you hold it. Some products also charge a fee when you buy. A yearly rate can look small, but the longer you hold, the larger the total.
- Themed funds often concentrate on one field, so if that field does poorly, the whole fund can fall together.
- I had not checked whether it overlapped with the funds I already held.
- When a distribution is paid, the fund’s price (its net asset value) falls by that amount. The nature of distributions differs by product, so receiving one is not necessarily a gain. You can read more in explanations such as those from the Investment Trusts Association.
Why one might pass
“Because it is No. 1” gives no help in deciding whether to keep holding when the price later falls. I could not explain in my own words what it invests in, what it costs, and how it overlaps with what I already own, so I passed. There is no need to judge this decision by how the price moves afterwards.
What this case shows
- Rankings and gains are past results. Check what the fund actually invests in.
- Think of the total of the trust fee and other costs over the period you would hold it.
- Check whether it overlaps with the products you already own.
Related: Why record the deals you passed on: a checklist for skipping decisions
We also welcome your own story of an investment you passed on. Send your story.
This article is a story rebuilt from examples shared by readers, with details changed so that no individual can be identified. Some numbers and conditions are illustrations. It is not a recommendation of any product or investment. Investment funds do not guarantee principal and can fall in value.
Found this useful? Let us know (anonymous).
Read next
Passing on gold in a hurry after hearing it hit a record high
Gold in the news at a record high; why the reader could not explain the reason to own it and passed
Related articles
Pausing on Japanese government bonds for individuals after hearing “the government issues them, so they are safe”
A bank counter pitch for retail government bonds; why the reader put the money aside until its purpose was clear
Passing on a crypto asset promoted as “sure to go up”
A coin promoted on social media as "sure to rise 10 times"; why the reader could not explain it and passed
Passing on a stock bought only for its shareholder perks
Price swings can outweigh the value of the perk. A story about passing when the perk is the only reason to buy.
Passing on a small stock that surged on social media buzz
A small stock surges in days on social media buzz. A story about passing when buzz is the only reason and nothing can be checked.